Home > Features > Film review: The Phantom of the Opera
Film review: The Phantom of the Opera
14th December 2004
The Phantom is obsessively in love with Christine. When he discovers that she has fallen for the opera's handsome and rich patron, Raoul, who was once her childhood sweetheart, the Phantom is overcome by a terrifying, violent jealousy. And I'm not surprised either, because Raoul looks like a girl, whereas the Phantom is a moody hunk with fabulous dress sense. Christine might have musical talent, but she has infuriatingly crap taste in men.
Obviously this is supposed to be the story of a tragic genius tortured by his disability, unable to be loved by a beautiful young woman because of his hideous face. Born disfigured, a flashback shows him as a child being horribly abused in a freak show and escaping to the sewers. The songs desperately want us to feel that if only the Phantom wasn't persecuted and mocked by society, he would be a rather nice chap. We're supposed to feel sympathy for him. But this is ruined by scenes such as the implied attempted rape of Christine, the Phantom wailing that his face has "denied me the joys of the flesh". Despite being a rather dark and sexy character (think Simon Cowell with sex appeal), he is also violent and nasty; it's difficult to feel any sympathy for a character so smothered in self-pity.
However, the greatest horror is undoubtedly reserved for what happens to the Phantom's hair. When the mask is ripped from his face, his previously slick black hair suddenly becomes rough and messy, with a large bald patch on his right side. I could have sworn that I even saw a blonde highlight. The director wants us to know that the Phantom has really lost his mind because his hair is now a mess. Yes, it really is that deep.
Perhaps the biggest mystery in this film is not what lies beneath the Phantom's mask, but rather: where does he buy his Brylcreem from? And where does he store his trouser press?
More articles about
Bookmark with...
Live community panel
Listen to our regular razor sharp talk show online, or subscribe to it as a podcast. Spread the word: it's where disability and reality almost collide.
More from the ³ÉÈËÂÛ̳
All the latest news from the paralympics.
News and views for people who are blind or partially sighted.
Weekdays 12.40pm. Radio 4's consumer affairs programme.
Comments