成人论坛

THIS TRANSCRIPT WAS TYPED FROM A RECORDING AND NOT COPIED FROM AN ORIGINAL SCRIPT.听 BECAUSE OF THE RISK OF MISHEARING AND THE DIFFICULTY IN SOME CASES OF IDENTIFYING INDIVIDUAL SPEAKERS THE 成人论坛 CANNOT VOUCH FOR ITS COMPLETE ACCURACY

听

FACE THE FACTS

The Country Rogue 听

听

Presenter: John Waite
Producer: Richard Hooper

听

TRANSMISSION: Wednesday 16th April 2014听 1230-1300听听听听听听听听 成人论坛 RADIO 4

听

(Door knocking)

听

Waite

This week we鈥檙e going back in time鈥�

听

Actuality 鈥� door opens

Waite

Hello Mr Phillips.听 John Waite from Radio 4.

听

Waite

Twenty years, in fact鈥�

听

Actuality

Phillips

I wrote to you yesterday and that is the letter of my response.听 And I鈥檝e got nothing further to add to that thank you.

听

Waite

We asked you several questions 鈥� Mr Phillips, Mr Phillips鈥�.[door slamming]

听

Waite

In 1994, Face the Facts investigated Desmond Phillips, a man who boasted of his skill in helping farmers who鈥檇 fallen on hard times. His clients told a very different story - how they faced ruined after doing business with him. 听Well today we find another group of his clients, farmers who in some cases have already lost or face losing the farms run by their families for decades, centuries even.

听

Montage

The way things is going we shan鈥檛 have nothing left, we shall be living under the hedges.

听

I feel as though I鈥檝e let everybody down, I鈥檓 the one that sold the family silver basically.

听

My husband鈥檚 family had been in this area for three generations.听 I suppose we make our own way in life now and we鈥檒l just have to see what happens.

听

Jim Goodland

I built all these 鈥� well had these sheds built and done some of the work meself.听 I鈥檝e put all my life into it really.听 When I worked for somebody else I saved all I could, we never got married or nothing, we put all our life into the farm鈥�

听

Ralph Goodland

..And it鈥檚 not been easy. There鈥檚 been a lot of hard work.

听

Waite

Fifty-six year old Ralph Goodland and his older brother Jim have a five acre farm near Axminster in Devon. They keep cows and sheep on their own land and help maintain farms for neighbouring landowners. They鈥檝e been there for nearly 30 years.

听

So how big a herd do you have Ralph?

听

Ralph Goodland

About 40 now, ain鈥檛 it?

听

Jim Goodland

We were gone up to 80, 80 or 90 cows when we had this extra ground but now we鈥檝e lost the ground we鈥檝e had to cut back.

听

Waite

That cutting back, had to start in the winter of 2011, when the brothers鈥� bank demanded they repay their听拢30,000 overdraft. For the Goodlands it left a huge hole in the farm finances. With difficult times ahead they were taken by a brochure they had picked up at an agricultural show. It contained a CD鈥�

听

Promotional CD

At UK we鈥檙e able to provide loans that others won鈥檛 consider because we believe in taking a bespoke view of our clients鈥� propositions.听 We鈥檙e happy to look at severe cases, such as bankruptcy, insolvency, or county court judgements.听 Our avowed aim is to deliver prosperity in adverse circumstances.

听

Waite

Definitely in adverse circumstances, the Goodlands rang the company using the freephone number in the brochure. Someone came to see them. A Mr Desmond Phillips.

听

So Mr Phillips came over?

听

Goodland

Mr Phillips came out on an internal meeting, yeah, he was a farmer, his son at his farm and then all the rest of it he told us.

听

Waite

On the same wavelength as you?

听

Goodland

Yeah, yeah he said he was a farmer yeah and he was telling about the tractors he had and that.听 Farmers trust farmers like you know.

听

We did initially think we鈥檇 have to sell the cows, he said no need to do that we can make the business more profitable, offered us this money for the new shed and more stock.

听

Waite

So how much money are we talking about there?

听

Goodland

On the valuation they came back with they could do 拢117,000.

听

Waite

He could find you a loan of 拢117,000?

听

Goodland

Yeah, yeah.

听

Waite

So the money was going to go on a new barn, a new cowshed and to pay off your overdraft?

听

Goodland

Yeah and the extra stock would have brought in that extra income and get us back into a bank.

听

Waite

The Goodlands were offered a high interest loan from a lender called UK Acorn Finance Limited based in Somerset. A company founded by Desmond Phillips.

听

According to Graham Redman, a partner at The Andersons Centre, a firm of agricultural business consultants, it is in the nature of farming that farmers can find themselves facing cash-flow problems and in need of financial help.

听

Redman

There are all sorts of reasons that make farm businesses rather volatile.听 Over the last couple of years we鈥檝e had some fairly extreme weather conditions, everyone will remember the rain we鈥檝e had and the cold weather this time last year, which has an impact on the amount of crops and livestock that farmers can produce.听 And as well the prices that farmers can sell their commodities for are enormously volatile.听 Most farmers have an overdraft facility which will go up and down throughout the season, it will go up and down more or less in different seasons according to that volatility that we鈥檝e just talked about.听 And if some farmers get really caught out then additional facilities are necessary in order that the farmer can pay for the liabilities as they come due for payment.

听

Waite

And how willing are regular banks to loan money to farmers who are suffering cash flow problems?

听

Redman

It is fair to say that it has become more difficult and certainly during 2010-2011 was probably the period when it was as tough as any.听 There were occasions when banks were saying well actually no we can鈥檛 extend that borrowing to you.

听

Waite

For farmers shunned by regular banks, Desmond Phillips and his company have an attractive sales pitch. Not only can they lend money, but they will help struggling farmers get to the stage where they can remortgage with a regular lender for a more regular rate of interest. Take this article from the Farmers Weekly in August 2010.

听

Farmers Weekly (Read)

鈥淥pportunity finance allows farmers a route to get from A to B, with a planned exit route at the end of it," said business founder Des Phillips. UK Farm Finance aimed to re-introduce customers to high street lenders at the end of the term, he added. "If we're not confident farmers won't achieve that exit route we won't lend鈥�.

听

What the article does not mention are the high interest rates and additional charges that come with these short term loans. In the case of the Goodland brothers, it was an array of what they say were unexpected add-ons. They had agreed a loan for 拢117,000, to pay off a 拢30,000 overdraft and to develop their business, by taking on more cows and building a new cowshed to house them.

听

Goodland
It was going to get rid of our overdraft, which we did do, by the time we鈥檇 done that, put the footings 鈥� or the foundations down for the new shed, but we never had the money to put the shed up, so it never got done.

听

Waite

So did you get 117鈥�.?

听

Goodland

No 鈥� 52 something went into the bank, that鈥檚 all we seen.

听

Waite

We have a copy of the loan agreement and it鈥檚 clear that what the Goodlands had signed for was a 12 month loan, charged at 21% interest, secured against their land and farm buildings. The interest was to be paid up front and an array of extra fees are also listed鈥�

听

An arrangement fee of 4%, a 0.5% borrowing and repayment fee, a charge for a borrowing repayment proposal, a 1% fee for quote 鈥渕onitoring the borrower鈥檚 business,鈥� a debt service reserve payment (at 3.5% cent over the Coutts base rate), and a charge of 1% to cover the lender鈥檚 legal fees. All this to help two farmers in their 50s overcome severe money problems. Or as the CD put it remember:

听

Promotional CD

Our avowed aim is to deliver prosperity in adverse circumstances.

听

Waite

Without the money they needed to expand and with no sign of that long term conventional finance which seemed so attractive, the Goodlands were unable to meet repayments on the loan. When they defaulted, the loan switched to a higher interest rate 鈥� 24% 鈥� and at the last count, the debt stood at 拢160,000, rising by more than a 拢100 a day.

听

UK Acorn Finance have told us that all borrowers, including the Goodlands, were required to have independent advice and legal representation so that they fully understood the terms of the agreement.

听

Not only that, the contract the Goodlands signed makes no mention of any long term finance which they claim made the deal so attractive. Having trusted the sales pitch of a fellow farmer, they now face repossession of their farm.

听

Goodland
I鈥檝e come back some nights and I don鈥檛 show it to Ralph, I have been in tears, I always come down here last thing at night to see the cows or my girls, as I call them, and they鈥檙e like 鈥� well they are my family I suppose.听 Just hope that something can be done to save them but I can see most of them now will be, well, literally slaughtered because we鈥檝e got no option.

听

Harvey

I can see that most of them will realise with the benefit of hindsight that they have been rather foolish.

听

Waite

Sir Nick Harvey, MP for North Devon, is one of several MPs who have received complaints from their constituents about Desmond Phillips. In January this year, a group of them met with Avon and Somerset Police to discuss whether they could investigate but the police explained they had insufficient evidence and no grounds to commence a criminal investigation. According to Sir Nicholas, many of the farmers say that they too received a promise that long term finance, at a lower interest rate, would follow the high interest bridging loan.

听

Harvey

All of them believe that they have made a long term arrangement, all of them believe that all their troubles have been answered, they have found a good stable satisfactory way to put themselves on the path back to stability and gradually they find that they鈥檙e losing everything they ever cherished.

听

Waite

So where was Desmond Phillips acquiring his funds to be in a position to advertise loans to farmers in hardship? 听Well we鈥檝e discovered that it was from an investment fund called Connaught 鈥� a collection of wealthy individuals and institutional investors looking for a healthy return and a quite separate entity from Phillips鈥� company UK Acorn Finance. We can also reveal they鈥檝e had little return on their investment. In late 2010, financial advisers were circulating their clients with news of an investment opportunity indicating a substantial rate of return for investments in British agriculture.

听

Investment Opportunity Prospectus (Read)

Confidential information memorandum from the Connaught Income Fund, Series 3

This is a potentially very attractive investment opportunity鈥� ideally placed to take advantage of the current squeeze in lending to farmers from traditional bank sources鈥μ� Suitable for the cautious investor.

听

The prospectus explained that the fund had partnered with a company that specialised in lending to farmers 鈥� UK Acorn Finance. The loans would be strictly short-term, high interest bridging loans, that would allow farmers to get a new business project off the ground. At the end of it, the farmers鈥� prospects would have improved, and they would be in a strong position to remortgage with a traditional lender like a high street bank and investors would get their money back. For a minimum of 拢20,000, investors could expect a return of 8.5% a year. The prospectus also made much of the credentials of the founder of the partner company 鈥� yes you鈥檝e guessed it, Mr Desmond Phillips.

听

Investment Opportunity Prospectus (Read)

Des has successfully formed and led a number of different enterprises throughout his long business career spanning over 40 years.... Des is still an active farmer today and maintains a high profile in farming circles.

听

Surrey chartered surveyor Jimmy Hearn was impressed and decided to invest.

听

Hearn

I can understand what it鈥檚 like when you鈥檙e starting out with a new business venture, people look at it and they take perhaps a jaundiced view, so I know how hard it is and this seemed to me to be a great opportunity to support farmers and farming and for me to get some return out of it and make some money and to assist farmers in getting new projects up and running.

听

Waite

And here鈥檚 the bit about Des Phillips, what did you make of that?

听

Hearn

He looked good actually, he鈥檚 described as a consultant to the business, he appeared to have good experience in the farming business and could introduce leads and connections and look to be a valuable member of the team.

听

Waite

Jimmy Hearn, as recommended by his financial adviser, invested some tens of thousands of pounds into the fund. He doesn鈥檛 want us to broadcast exactly how much. Documents we鈥檝e obtained show that fellow investors included the likes of Scottish Widows, Legal and General and Clerical Medical. In total, over 拢22 million was raised to lend to farmers. But in late 2012, investors received worrying news from Connaught. The fund investment assumed that only 15% of the loans would default but in a letter they were told:

听

Connaught Letter (Read)

鈥� at present, all of the loans in the portfolio are in technical default.

听

In other words the Goodlands in Axminster were not the only farmers struggling to pay a loan set up by Desmond Phillips鈥� company. The news puzzled investor Jimmy Hearn.

听

Hearn

If the interest had been paid up front I couldn鈥檛 understand what the farmers could have done to have caused their loans to go into default, what else was there apart from I suppose lawyers鈥� fees and debt recovery fees which I was hoping wouldn鈥檛 eat too much into the capital.

听

Waite

And how likely is it all of them would be?

听

Hearn

Oh it鈥檚 so unlikely it鈥檚 unbelievable.

听

Waite

Not for the first time, a company run by Desmond Phillips is at the centre of controversy. Back in 1994, Face the Facts reported how a group of disgruntled farmers claimed they had been failed by Mr Phillips鈥� then company, Baybrook, no connection with any other company of a similar name. In some cases farmers claimed they had lost everything because long term finance, they believed would be forthcoming, never materialised. At the time, Mr Phillips was an undischarged bankrupt, a fact I was keen to clarify when I tried to get an interview with him.

听

Actuality

Waite

Home and the Baybrook HQ turned out to be a handsome Georgian farmhouse at the end of a quarter of a mile drive.听 But the welcome was as frosty as the Somerset snow.

听

Door knocking

听

I鈥檓 here to record an interview with you now about why you鈥檙e running Baybrook Agriculture whilst an undischarged bankrupt.

听

Phillips

I wrote to you yesterday and that is the letter of my response鈥�. I鈥檝e got nothing further to add to that.听 Thank you.

听

Waite

We asked you several questions鈥�. Mr Phillips, Mr Phillips鈥�.[door slamming]

听

Waite

I never did get an interview although Mr Phillips did give us a statement to indicate that far from running a company while an undischarged bankrupt, he had been working for his wife. At the time, the National Farmers Union told the programme that they had received a 鈥渇lood of complaints鈥� about his then business, prompting a spokesman to issue this advice to members.

听

NFU Advice (Read)

If farmers are in financial difficulties come to the NFU, go to a reputable consultant but don鈥檛 touch Des Phillips with a bargepole.

听

Well, many who have encountered Desmond Phillips throughout his career have reached the same conclusion.听

听

Read

In 1975, Desmond Phillips (22) is declared bankrupt with debts of over 拢90,000. An agricultural contracting business he was running collapsed leaving a number of creditors.

听

Fast forward to 1976鈥�

听

Read

Desmond Phillips pleads guilty to stealing two tractors and a hay baler.

听

Mr Phillips told us he has never been convicted of any criminal offence, but then changed his mind when we referred him to the records of Shepton Mallet magistrates鈥� court. Mr Phillips now says that the company he stole the machinery from was repaid in full and he hadn鈥檛 realised it would be recorded as a criminal offence.听

听

He was later discharged from bankruptcy and in 1987...

听

Read

Mr Phillips鈥� timber and haulage business collapses with creditors left owed nearly 拢300,000.

听

Four years later:

听

Read

His company that brokers endowment policies is wound up. Many of his customers are farmers and insurance companies claim they are owed 拢300,000 on commissions paid out on policies that either failed to materialise or were subsequently cancelled.

听

Another year later in 1992:

听

Read

Mr Phillips is declared bankrupt for a second time, with debts of 拢170,000.

听

Having been discharged from bankruptcy in the late鈥�90s, Mr Phillips was soon back in business. A gap now but in 2008 at Manchester High Court:

听

听

Read

A judgment of 拢250,000 is recorded against him personally.

听

That judgment was paid but today you will find Mr Phillips on the insolvency register, after entering into an individual voluntary arrangement in 2010 because of his debts - debts he says that result from the credit crunch.

听

We鈥檝e found 14 court judgments from the last six years against his companies 鈥� from courts in Truro to Glasgow - cases where individuals and companies said they had not been paid for goods and services. Some of which have now been satisfied

听

Meanwhile the liquidators of another of Mr Phillips鈥� businesses, UK Country Capital Ltd., which went into administration in 2011, say it owed Barclays Capital 拢17.3 million before it went under. Mr Phillips again attributes this failure to the credit crunch.

听

Nevertheless, it鈥檚 a record which staggers those who invested in the Connaught fund, designed to help farmers.

听

So you had no idea about Mr Phillips鈥� bankruptcies?

听

Hearn

No.

听

Waite

Did you know about his criminal conviction?

听

Hearn

No.

听

Waite

His many business failures?

听

Hearn

No.

听

Waite

What would you have done if you had known about these things?

听

Hearn

I wouldn鈥檛 have gone near this fund with a bargepole.听 Wouldn鈥檛 have touched it.听 Wouldn鈥檛 have touched it at all.

听

Waite

The operators of the Connaught fund refused to reveal to us what due diligence they undertook before forming a partnership with Desmond Phillips and his company UK Acorn Finance. In a statement they say:

听

听

Connaught Fund Statement

We are in regular communication with the investors and will be sure to alert them to a number of the points you have raised. However, the defaulting loans are subject to on-going court proceedings and it would not therefore be appropriate for us to comment.

听

Pengelly

Where we鈥檙e standing we can see all family farms here that join at one point there and the farms join down on that land, we鈥檙e all cousins.听 The family farmed a lot of this land around here, right back 鈥� well, back into the early 1600s.

听

Waite

One of those on-going proceedings is with Miles Pengelly who showed me what was once his 185 acre mixed farm near Padstow in Cornwall. In 2011, he was in financial trouble, having added an ice cream business to the family farm, but suffering from successive poor tourist seasons. Having had his annual EU subsidy payment disqualified, Miles was unable to meet repayments on a loan. With the lender threatening repossession, Desmond Phillips鈥� company said they could help.

听

Pengelly

We agreed short term high rate finance followed up by a longer term arrangement at a much more favourable rate.听 Now, I explained to him in great detail that I couldn鈥檛 afford to pay the short term rates any longer than the six month initial period.听

听

Waite

UK Acorn Finance lent Mr Pengelly 拢130,000 at a rate of 21%. An amount, he says, he could only repay if a long-term loan at a lower interest rate was put in place.听 But six months later, as with the Goodlands over in Devon, there was no sign of that long term finance.

听

Pengelly

I rang them and asked for people 鈥� I was always told they weren鈥檛 in the office or they鈥檙e away doing business, they were doing this, they were doing that but they would never answer the phone to me.听 On the sixth month anniversary of the loan I had a letter calling the loan in.

听

Waite

What did you make of that?

听

Pengelly

I thought that at the end of the six months it would roll right into the next finance agreement, I certainly wouldn鈥檛 expect them to have the loan called in.听 Obviously the funds weren鈥檛 there and I would suggest that they knew it.听 And they were in actual fact not particularly worried, they were getting a good rate of interest and they weren鈥檛 too concerned about repossessing property either.听 This has almost made me think there was never ever going to be any further finance and in actual fact I鈥檇 just been caught basically.

听

Waite

Mr Pengelly鈥檚 land was eventually repossessed by UK Acorn Finance. The land sold at auction for less than it had been valued and because by then the debt had risen considerably, Mr Pengelly is still being pursued by the company for a shortfall it says he owes them. One puzzling aspect of the case is that Mr Pengelly admits he needed the loan to solve a severe financial problem and he says he made that clear to the lenders, yet in the prospectus, which Connaught used to attract investors, it says the lending would be for extending or developing a business. In other words NOT for shoring up a struggling one.听

听

Actuality 鈥� Sylvia Eckley

Oh you want to see that one. Hay Bluff and the Black Mountains right down the valleys to the Golden Valley 鈥� no view in that area was as wonderful as that chalet.

听

Waite

Meanwhile Sylvia and David Eckley who have farmed sheep at Clyro on the Welsh border near Hay on Wye for 50 years, were certainly extending their business when they got involved with UK Acorn Finance. With the encouragement of the Welsh Tourist Board, like many landowners in the region, they obtained planning permission for two holiday chalets which would cost 拢100,000 to build. The Eckleys鈥� bank was unwilling to lend the money. UK Acorn Finance offered to step in.

听

Eckley

It was stated that we could have a bridging loan with the view that when the six months was up we would be offered firm finance from a reputable mortgage company.

听

Waite

But you and your husband 鈥� you鈥檙e into your 60s 鈥� was it really likely you were going to get a long term financial loan?

听

Sylvia Eckley

Well, we were told we were going to get one.听 There was no two ways.听 So we had no reason to doubt it.

听

Waite

In all the Eckleys borrowed over 拢300,000, enough not only to build the holiday chalets but to pay off an existing mortgage. But they too claim they were shocked when they received a bill for additional charges that came with the loan.

听

Sylvia Eckley

Well arrangement fee was 拢11,000, lender鈥檚 fee was 拢4,000, business plan was 拢2,200, monitoring fee 拢2,200, valuation 拢2,000, advice 拢2,000 and service charge.听 Looking at it鈥� it鈥檚 just unbelievable.

听

Waite

Sylvia and David Eckley also now faced a rapidly rising debt. Their six month loan term had come to an end, but again, there was no sign of that conventional mortgage they say they were promised would be awaiting them. Unable to pay back the UK Acorn Finance loan and those additional charges they were threatened with eviction. One day a neighbouring farmer called with news: he had spotted their farm up for auction.

听

Sylvia Eckley

It was devastating basically.听 But then you weren鈥檛 treated as a person, it was a commodity.听

听

Waite

So the farm was repossessed?

听

Sylvia Eckley

Yes.

听

Waite

And where we鈥檙e sitting 鈥� this is rented?

听

Sylvia Eckley

Yes, we haven鈥檛 got 鈥� we haven鈥檛 got anything basically, we haven鈥檛 got any stock and I suppose we鈥檙e just retired.听 We have been retired.

听

Waite

We鈥檝e traced many of the farmers who borrowed money from UK Acorn Finance. At the last count, 22 of them are still to pay the loans back, and in some cases are fighting the company in the courts to prevent repossession of their farms. Others have already lost their farms 鈥� one told us he鈥檚 currently living in a caravan. But all make the same accusation - that they were promised long-term finance, and when it didn鈥檛 materialize, they were saddled with a debt they could never afford to repay. Jimmy Hearn unwittingly invested in the whole enterprise, and he has had little return on his outlay and severely regrets getting involved.

听

Hearn

I think they鈥檝e got a very raw deal out of this and if there was any way in which I could reinvest the money in a fund that supported them I would do so straightaway.听 I鈥檓 not in a good position here but they鈥檙e in a terrible position.

听

Waite

We did invite Desmond Phillips and UK Acorn Finance to give an interview. They declined and accused us of making 鈥渂aseless and wholly inappropriate鈥� allegations about Mr Phillips personally. In a statement, we were told:

听

UK Acorn Finance Statement (Read)

UK Acorn Finance did not offer long term finance and did not promise to do so. None of the companies involved, nor Mr Phillips, offered advice to any clients in relation to any matter.

听

The strict requirement of UK Acorn Finance was at all times for borrowers to provide their own repayment proposals which would deal with the exit from the lending, before we were prepared to lend. Borrowers were required to have independent advice in connection with this.

听

The claimants鈥� allegations have already been subject to court proceedings and there are judgments in our favour.

听

Waite

We asked UK Acorn Finance to explain why so many farmers defaulted on their loans. Their explanation was that, and I quote: 鈥渟adly the business plans of some borrowers failed and they were unable to repay their loans as originally intended鈥� and that 鈥渢here was no alternative to taking enforcement action through the courts鈥�. 听

听

Well, MP Sir Nicky Harvey is now calling on the government to investigate why so many farmers say they now face ruin after doing business with Desmond Phillips and his company.

听

Harvey

There certainly seems to be a gap in the legislation and it鈥檚 the intention of the MPs who gathered and spoke to the police to ask both the Department for Business and the Select Committee for Business to have a look at this issue, investigate it and see if there is a need for legislation here.

听

Waite

And when you talk to your colleague MPs does the name Desmond Phillips crop up?

听

Harvey

Well, it鈥檚 very much his enterprise that we鈥檙e discussing. It鈥檚 not particularly that we personalise it to him but I think the spider at the centre of the web does indeed seem to be him.

听