成人论坛

Evaluating - EdexcelEvaluating against the specification

Evaluating ideas, models and feedback is an ongoing process, utilised in continuing to adapt and improve products to make them more useful, appealing and profitable.

Part of Design and TechnologyNEA project skills

Evaluating against the specification

Creating and working with design specifications and design briefs

Designers will have written a , developed from the and based on the results of completed research. This is where a specific list of is written that a designer can follow as a set of rules. During the iterative design process, this specification should be referenced to and designs evaluated against it to ensure the final solution is the best fit.

Six different design criteria, function, materials, environment, performance, target market and aesthetics all illustrated around a main central label saying 鈥楧esign specification鈥.

Considerations might include:

  • How does the product fit within the range of sizes specified?
  • Does the product fit the client鈥檚 taste?
  • Do the materials and components fit within the specified cost limits?
  • Does the product appeal to the ?
  • Will the design comply with current safety standards?
  • Will the product have a minimal impact on the environment?

Evaluation is part of the process, a circular design process that models, evaluates and improves designs based on the results of testing.

Diagram illustrating the cyclic iterative design process starting with a brief, to analysis, design ideas, modelling, testing, evaluating and modification.

The iterative design process works by the feedback received and evaluating against the specification criteria to determine the effectiveness of the product and consequently to redevelop the product. Further improvements can be made and then more feedback can be gathered until both the and the target market are happy with the outcome.

Without the iterative cycle of and improvement from both the client and the target market, the product may not be the best on the market. This will allow another manufacturer to produce a better product that will be more successful.