Sharleen Spiteri - 'All The Times I Cried'
Everyone's on about the Winehouse-ettes at the minute. Well, by 'everyone' and 'on about' I do mean several broadsheet articles earlier this year but even so, there's an awful lot of white British women doing funky soul/Motown-influenced songs and I'm sure they're all doing it totally of their own volition and not due to cynical marketing ploys at all but it does all seem to have happened in the wake of 'Back To Black''s surprising success
In fact, female singers seem stuck in the difficult catch-22 of this faux-Motown vibe being simultaneously code for credibility and also an increasingly trend-degraded and credibility-destroying sound. Such is the way with the fickle world of popular music; first it giveth, then it slappeth you on the front of a gossip magazine and screams "SLAPPER!"
Sharleen Spiteri, though, as the distinctive 'voice of Texas,' doesn't quite need an instant hit of fame with a particularly fashionable sound. So why, you might ask, does her debut solo single (and I'll swear she did one of them a few years ago but maybe not, since the internet provides no evidence to this effect) fit into the whole 'Wine-ettes' thing?
I don't know, obviously, not being privy to either Sharleen's mind or the happenings in the recording studio when this was created but I can't help but have it strike me as an odd move.
Sharleen, of course, is considerably older and more experienced in the ways of the music world than the Winehouse-ettes and it would seem rather ridiculous to lump her as a copyist of an artist who emerged long after Sharleen herself established a successful music career, snogging Alan Rickman in videos and inspiring a million androgynous haircuts. Whilst I understand the desire to do something markedly different from Texas in order to define herself as a solo artist and see that Sharleen's expressive voice is actually very well suited to a personal take on the genre, I have to admit I find it slightly confusing that she's released this as a first solo single.
The video seems to express it all, with the break-up conversation at the start a not-particularly-subtle metaphor for breaking with her previous work and her change in appearance, suddenly very regimented, styled hair and a girly dress, rather than her usual choppy, almost boyish bob and indie jeans. I'm willing to think this is something to do with the dignity of age, as well as a desire to change herself into a solo artist since you can't carry on dressing like it's 1998 forever but it's quite a shocking change.
What's the oddest in all this, of course, is that 'All The Times I Cried' actually sounds very, very Texas somehow. Not just because of Sharleen's voice but something about the whole song sounds really very like 'In Demand.' Texas of course always did a have a little of the retro swing to them, like in 'Black Eyed Boy' and so it's not a totally unnatural leap for her to have made something more overtly in that direction but it's quite odd how simultaneously surprising and well, almost generically Texas it sounds.
Generically Texas, of course, is better than a lot of things; the band have always had a brilliant knack for crafting a catchy tune and Sharleen's voice is very emotionally evocative, so this ballad sweeps around you in a lovely manner, never quite reaching absolutely stellar status but nevertheless being far, far more than pleasant. The only complaint I can really make against it is that I don't think much of the lyrics, especially given Sharleen's created some really interesting ones in the past- listening to it to review it, I've got very sick of the phrase "how am supposed to dream when nothing's ever what it seems?" which seems to repeat endlessly in the song.
Despite that particular gripe, though and the fact the talk-y bits in the video detract massively from the song (the fact it crashes its own vocal at the start seems more than slightly insane) this is a lovely song, especially for a break up and it's wonderfully summery. It'll probably be a big hit and if not, it'd be overlooked undeservedly.
So, with that, I suppose the only question remaining is is that actually Jarvis Cocker in the video or just a man that looks an incredibly amount like him?
Download: Out now
CD Released: July 7th
(Hazel Robinson)
Comment number 1.
At 6th Jul 2008, sambda wrote:Are Ellie Greenwich and Jeff Barry suing? This is a cover version, folks.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 1)
Comment number 2.
At 6th Jul 2008, HazelChartblog wrote:Srsly, I should do more research, this is what comes of suddenly having access to Freeview music channels and no longer having to put actual effort in to hear new releases. How embarassing.
I assume they're credited, if it's a cover. I doubt Sharleen et al have just waltzed off with the song, given the writers are so well known. This does of course cast light on the fact it's not retro-stylings but actual retro, too.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 2)
Comment number 3.
At 7th Jul 2008, kookie25 wrote:whats a shame is, some people will probably think that Sharleen *is* just jumping on the 'motown' type of band wagon, when in fact any Texas fan would know that her and the band have always been influenced by this era of music, and pre or post winehouse would probably have produced similar solo material.
As Texas fan, i'm not sure what i think of the stuff yet, i'll have to have a listen of the album. Hope it does do well though, as i've not been too keen on the later Texas stuff.
More funds for indie look Shar though :-)
Complain about this comment (Comment number 3)
Comment number 4.
At 7th Jul 2008, Fraser McAlpine - wrote:I think Sambda might have been saying the song contains several melodic lifts from Greenwich/Barry's Shangri-Las songs. Most specifically 'Out In The Streets', which has almost exactly the same vocal melody.
It's certainly not an actual cover version. The BMI website is very clear on this.
It's retro stylings, just like Sharleen's video wig is Winehouse styling.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 4)
Comment number 5.
At 5th Jan 2009, issovia wrote:One of the better voices for me and I believe also for those who him they remember from their Texas. The particular song they is good other no as long as Stop the Don't Lobe You Anymore (look here: . I wish best for the Sharleen.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 5)